Can a DWI Blood Test Be Thrown Out?
People often ask whether they can “beat” a DWI blood test. The better question is whether the State can prove the blood test was lawfully obtained, properly administered, reliably tested, and admissible in court.
In a recent Hennepin County DWI case, the answer was no.
The State had a reported blood test result. But a lab number does not walk into evidence on its own. Before the State can use a blood test in court, it must satisfy the rules of evidence and the Constitution.
The court granted our motion to suppress the blood test result after the State could not produce the person who drew the blood. We demanded that witness because a forensic blood draw is not just paperwork. It is part of the test.
The court agreed that our client had the constitutional right to confront that witness.
Then the case took a surprising turn. Rather than appeal the ruling or proceed to trial without the blood result, the State dismissed both DWI charges in exchange for a plea to careless driving.
That is why the fight over evidence matters.
Key Takeaways
- A DWI blood test does not begin at the lab.
- The State must prove more than a final number.
- The person who drew the blood may be a necessary witness.
- Suppressing the blood test changed the leverage in this case.
- Both DWI charges were dismissed in exchange for a careless driving plea.
Can You Fight a Minnesota DWI Blood Test?
Yes. A Minnesota DWI blood test can be challenged in several ways.
The defense may challenge the warrant, the blood draw, the handling of the sample, the testing method, the lab result, the witnesses, or the State’s ability to get the result admitted in court.
The final number on a lab report is not the same thing as admissible evidence.
That difference decided this issue. The State wanted to use the blood test result, but it could not produce the person who administered the forensic blood draw. Because we had demanded that witness, the court suppressed the result.
Once that happened, the case changed. The charge changed. The leverage changed.
Why the Blood-Draw Witness Matters
In many DWI blood-test cases, the State focuses on the final number reported by the crime lab. But a blood test does not begin at the lab. It begins when a person collects blood from the accused.
That process involves more than simply placing blood into a tube. The person who draws the blood may need to answer questions about:
- whether the correct person was identified;
- whether the draw site was prepared properly;
- whether alcohol-containing products were avoided;
- whether the correct tubes were used;
- whether the tubes contained the proper preservative and anticoagulant;
- whether the tubes were filled, mixed, sealed, labeled, and stored correctly;
- whether anything unusual happened during the draw;
- whether the documentation accurately reflects what occurred.
If the person who administered the forensic blood draw is not available for cross-examination, the defense loses the ability to ask critical questions about what actually happened.
That is not a paperwork problem. It is a constitutional problem.
Why Suppressing the Blood Test Changed the Case
The Constitution gives an accused person the right to confront the witnesses the State uses to prove its case. In a DWI blood-test case, that can include the person who administered the forensic blood draw.
The State may argue that the blood test result is reliable because the lab tested the sample. But reliability is not the whole question. The Confrontation Clause requires reliability to be tested through cross-examination.
That was the key issue here. The State wanted to use the blood test result, but it could not produce the person who administered the blood draw. Because we had demanded that witness, and because the State could not present that witness, the court suppressed the blood test result.
Blood-test evidence is often the centerpiece of a DWI prosecution. When the blood result is suppressed, the State loses one of its most powerful pieces of evidence.
Here, that changed everything. Rather than appeal or try the case without the blood test, the State dismissed both DWI charges in exchange for a careless driving plea. That was a dramatic change in posture from a prosecutor who had previously rejected a similar resolution.
Good lawyering can make that happen. So can preparation, persistence, knowing the case law, demanding the right witnesses, and sometimes catching the break when the moment finally arrives.
Years of DWI Litigation Made the Difference
This result did not happen by accident.
We demanded the presence of the person who drew the blood. We preserved the confrontation issue. We were prepared on the case law. And the court relied, in part, on Minnesota precedent from a case Chuck Ramsay appealed and won more than twenty years ago.
That earlier appeal was not academic. It became the law that helped suppress the blood test in this case.
More than twenty years later, that appellate win still protects people accused of impaired driving in Minnesota.
Experience in this narrow area of DWI law matters. Sometimes the winning issue is not obvious unless the defense knows which witness to demand and why.
Blood and Urine Test Results Are Not Automatic Losses
This case involved the State’s inability to produce the person who drew the blood for cross-examination. But that is only one of many ways blood and urine test evidence can be attacked in a Minnesota DWI case.
Ramsay Law Firm has recently challenged and defeated blood and urine test evidence for several different reasons, including:
- bad warrants, where the State did not have proper legal authority to obtain the sample. Blood and urine tests generally require a warrant or a recognized exception.
- urine test rounding, where the reported result was rounded up in a way that changed the legal significance of the test. In one case, the BCA reported a urine result as .08 even though the machine measured .079, and the judge reinstated the client’s license.
- prescription drug defenses, where the State tried to treat lawful medication use as criminal impairment. A positive drug test does not automatically prove impairment, especially when the medication was prescribed and taken at therapeutic levels.
- collection, handling, and testing problems, where questions about how the blood test sample was collected, preserved, transported, tested, or reported undermined the State’s case.
The lesson is straightforward: a blood or urine test result is not the end of a DWI case. For the defense, it is often where the real work begins.
The State still has to prove the test was lawfully obtained, properly administered, scientifically reliable, and admissible in court. When the government cannot meet those requirements, the result may be suppressed, excluded, or weakened in front of a jury.
What This Means if You Are Charged with DWI
If you are charged with a DWI involving a blood test or urine test, do not assume the test result automatically comes into evidence.
The defense should examine whether the police had legal authority to obtain the sample, whether the correct procedures were followed, whether the State can produce the necessary witnesses, whether the sample was properly collected and tested, whether the reported result accurately reflects the evidence, and whether constitutional objections apply.
A lab number is powerful evidence only if the State can lawfully get it into court and prove that it means what the State says it means.
Before anyone treats a blood or urine test as the end of a DWI case, the defense should ask the questions the State hopes no one asks.
Ramsay Law Firm PLLC defends DWI cases throughout Minnesota, including cases involving blood tests, urine tests, breath tests, forensic testing, chemical-test evidence, and constitutional challenges.




